All American Gutter Protection Review | 2025 Guide
All products and services featured are independently selected by our editors. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission.
All American Gutter Protection is a veteran gutter guard provider that stood out for its system’s corrosion resistance and low-profile design. As one of the best gutter guards we reviewed, All American offers a balance of functional features, aesthetic appeal, and value.
Our team crafted a thorough methodology to evaluate gutter guard companies, rating them on debris blockage performance, installation process, brand reputation, and more. We also analyzed thousands of consumer reviews to gauge customer experience. Use our guide to assess All American Gutter Protection and decide whether you should hire the company to install gutter guards on your home.
Our Summary and Review of All American Gutter Protection
- Material: Stainless steel
- Style: Micro-mesh
- Durability: Rust- and corrosion-resistant
- Debris Blockage: Leaves, pine needles, seedpods, shingle grit, and twigs
All American Gutter Protection provides micro-mesh gutter guards, which are the most effective type of gutter guard. These guards can block everything from leaves and twigs to shingle grit and pine needles. They’re also aesthetically pleasing, with a low-profile design that doesn’t detract from your home’s design.
We’re particularly impressed with All American Gutter Protection’s flexible installation and the minimal upkeep its gutter guards require. All American Gutter Protection can install its guards on existing gutters and offers removal services, which some competitors, such as Leafguard, don’t provide.
While All American Gutter Protection is one of the highest-rated gutter guard providers we reviewed, it has some drawbacks. The biggest flaw we found is the company’s lack of a lifetime transferable warranty, which would transfer to the next homeowner should you decide to sell your home.
Key competitors such as Leafguard, LeafFilter, Gutter Guards America, and HomeCraft offer this perk. A transferable warranty could be a selling point to prospective buyers who aren’t eager to clean the gutters on their new home or replace the guards if they malfunction, which could increase your home value.
The company website also lacks details about the terms and conditions of its warranties, prompting you to contact a representative for more information. We contacted a representative for additional insight on the warranty’s terms and exclusions.
The representative emailed us a more detailed breakdown of the warranty’s coverages and exclusions than the information provided online and followed up with a phone call to address any further questions. While the lack of policy information on the company website is a drawback, we were impressed with All American Gutter Protection’s thorough response.
Pros
- Offers a 10% discount to seniors, military members, and veterans
- Blocks small debris such as shingle grit and pine needles
- Features a low-profile design with minimal visibility
- Provides gutter cleaning, installation, and downspout replacement
- Uses stainless steel micro-mesh screens with durable aluminum frames
Cons
- Doesn’t offer a lifetime transferable warranty
- Outsources installation jobs to contractors
- Some complaints reference scheduling issues
All American Gutter Protection
Our Detailed Rating of All American Gutter Protection
Based on our rating system, All American Gutter Protection earned 4.2 out of 5 stars. Here are the metrics we used to score each gutter guard installer we reviewed:
- Services and features: We rated each company based on its materials, its product’s efficiency at blocking debris, and additional features such as gutter cleaning and downspout replacement.
- Reliability: This evaluated the company’s reputation, years of experience, state availability, and expertise.
- Cost and value: Our team analyzed the provider’s pricing, ongoing discounts and promotions, and warranties.
- Flexibility: We researched the company’s customer service, upkeep services, and ease of installation.
Read on for an overview of how All American Gutter Protection scored in each category.
Services and Features
When rating services and features, we reviewed a gutter guard’s materials, its ability to block debris from your gutters and downspouts, and additional features such as aesthetic appeal.
All American Gutter Protection scored 4.7 out of 5 stars in our evaluation of its services and features. Its micro-mesh gutter guards have an aluminum body and stainless steel screen, which prevent warping and corrosion over time.
This type of guard effectively blocks debris from your gutters, including small bits of shingle grit, which competitors such as Leafguard—a brand that installs reverse-curve gutter guards—struggle to keep out. The design is crucial to keeping your gutters clog-free, and it’s more aesthetically pleasing than other models.
Additionally, we’re satisfied with the company’s extra service offerings, which include gutter installation, gutter cleaning, and downspout replacement. These services are typical among competitors, although Leafguard doesn’t offer gutter cleaning.
Overall, we found the quality of All American Gutter Protection’s services and features to be on par with premier gutter guard companies such as LeafFilter.
Reliability
When scoring the company’s reliability, we examined its overall reputation, years in business, and level of expertise.
All American Gutter Protection scored 4.1 out of 5 stars for reliability. Founded in 2015, it has a longer history than competitors like Gutter Guards America.
While it lost points for being available in fewer than 20 states, our methodology identified it as a dependable pick if you live in Ohio or one of its other service areas.
All American Gutter Protection’s biggest shortcoming is its dependence on subcontractors to install gutter guards, while Leafguard and Gutter Guards America have in-house teams. However, the company is bonded, protecting you financially if the job fails to meet expectations or if damage or theft occurs.
Cost and Value
We considered a company’s pricing, promotions, and warranties to gauge its cost and value.
Unfortunately, All American Gutter Protection scored 2.8 out of 5 stars in our assessment of its cost and value, the lowest score out of all the providers we reviewed.
Similar to its competitors, the company offers a no-clog guarantee. However, we were disappointed that it lacks a 100% money-back guarantee, which Gutter Guards America, Leafguard, and LeafFilter provide.
Along those lines, All American Gutter Protection lacks a transferable warranty. Most competitors offer a lifetime performance warranty that covers your gutter guards for the life of your home, regardless of the owner.
We liked that the company offers discounts to military members and senior citizens, unlike Leafguard and HomeCraft.
We also loved that the company’s estimates are good for one year, giving you time to shop around before making a decision. This is typical for the industry, but one big competitor–Leafguard–falls short by not offering this benefit.
Flexibility
When scoring for flexibility, we evaluated a company’s customer support, upkeep, and ease of installation to see how the company simplifies the process.
All American Gutter Protection earned a perfect score of 5 out of 5 stars for flexibility. You can reach the company by phone or use a contact form on the website to schedule a complimentary on-site estimate.
Like most of its competitors that offer micro-mesh gutter guards, All American Gutter Protection’s product requires minimal upkeep. Its gutters are self-cleaning, with a built-in pitch that allows debris to roll off easily.
We also liked that, unlike Leafguard, All American Gutter Protection can install new gutter guards on your existing gutters and offers removal services. In addition to fitting existing gutters, we found that the company’s guards adapt well to various roof types.
All American Gutter Protection Product Overview
All American Gutter Protection’s micro-mesh gutter guards prevent clogs, divert water flow from heavy rain, and reduce the need to clean your gutters regularly. Due to the design of its guards, it’s a superior option to Leafguard if you live in a region with heavy rain.
Below are some details about the product’s makeup and maintenance.
Specs
All American Gutter Protection’s gutter guards are made in the USA with surgical-grade materials that are built to last.
Gutter Guard Screen
- Stainless steel micro-mesh
- Rust- and corrosion-resistant
Gutter Guard Frame
- 100% anodized aluminum body
- Resists warping and cracking
- Allows for a built-in pitch
- Installed at your roof’s pitch for a low-profile design
Gutter Guard Hangers
- Discreetly placed behind gutters
- Provides stability for gutter guards
Maintenance
All American Gutter Protection’s gutter guards require minimal maintenance. The stainless steel micro-mesh guards prevents most debris from settling in your gutters. The built-in pitch naturally guides debris off the gutters, which reduces the risk of clogs and minimizes the need to clean your gutters manually.
However, gutter guards don’t permanently eliminate the need for cleaning and maintenance. While the rain should wash away most debris, you should occasionally hose off your gutters. We recommend checking your gutters annually and after major storms to ensure they aren’t damaged.
All American Gutter Protection Reviews
We reviewed All American Gutter Protection’s nearly 1,000 online customer reviews, finding commonalities across numerous reviews on different platforms.
Our team discovered that many customers complimented the quality of All American Gutter Protection’s installation and performance and its team’s courteous and professional demeanor. Meanwhile, we saw other reviewers who complained about scheduling issues with the company’s subcontractors and high-pressure sales tactics.
We chose these reviews because they showcased some common praises and pain points expressed by All American Gutter Protection’s customers. Gary and other reviewers praised the technicians’ professionalism and installation. Yet Thomas’s review was one of several that called out the company for cancellations and delays.
We contacted an All American Gutter Protection representative for tips to ensure scheduling goes smoothly. They advised staying in contact with the customer service team if any issues arise and being patient in cases of inclement weather, which they cited as the main reason for cancellations.
Breakdown by Review Site
We primarily explored reviews published on the Better Business Bureau (BBB), Trustpilot, and Google Reviews to gauge customer experience. Here’s a look at how All American Gutter Protection responds to customers on these platforms:
- BBB: All American Gutter Protection is BBB-accredited and has an A rating, with 3.28 out of 5 stars. The company currently has a 100% response rate to customer complaints and appears to offer a genuine resolution to the issue raised.
- Trustpilot: The company is verified by Trustpilot and has a rating of 3.7 out of 5 stars. However, it only has one customer review, which the company hasn’t responded to, so we don’t put that much stock in it.
- Google Reviews: The company has a 4.7 out of 5-star rating on Google Reviews. Its representatives frequently respond to reviews and proactively schedule follow-ups to resolve complaints.
When we evaluated All American Gutter Protection’s reputation on online review sites, we saw several trends. It scored similarly to LeafFilter and HomeCraft and outscored Gutter Guards America on some platforms. It also scored significantly higher than Leafguard overall.
The majority of reviewers had positive experiences with the company, commending its courteous customer service and installation quality. A handful cited high-pressure sales pitches and scheduling problems.
We were impressed with All American Gutter Protection’s consistent responses to complaints. Rather than giving generic replies, the company directly addresses negative reviews, following up with customers and providing practical solutions.
*All review scores were accurate when published.
Compare All American Gutter Protection to Other Gutter Guard Companies
All American Gutter Protection offers corrosion-resistant and low-profile gutter protection systems. Compared to its competitors, it shines for including valuable services and offering rewarding discounts and promotions but falls short by failing to provide a transferable warranty.
| Company | Star Rating | Best For | BBB Rating | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Our Top Pick | A+ | GET ESTIMATE | ||
| Reverse Curve | A+ | GET ESTIMATE | ||
| Customer Reviews | A+ | GET ESTIMATE | ||
| Customization Options | A | GET ESTIMATE | ||
| Add-On Services | B | GET ESTIMATE |
Is All American Gutter Protection Worth It?
All American Gutter Protection can be worth the investment if you’re looking for a quality product to protect your gutters and live in one of the states it serves. The company is bonded and has a long track record as a reliable gutter guard installer.
Its corrosion-resistant gutter guards can adapt to most roofs and can be fitted over your existing gutters, eliminating the need to pay for new ones. You can count on the micro-mesh design to block debris of all sizes and enjoy minimal upkeep since the gutter guards are self-cleaning.
All American Gutter Protection might not be the best fit if you plan to sell your home in the future and want to include your gutter guards as a selling point since there’s no lifetime transferable warranty.
However, the volume of positive customer reviews and All American Gutter Protection’s prompt responses to complaints suggest that you can depend on the company to remedy issues while you own your home. Just note that scheduling delays and miscommunications with the company’s subcontractors can occur.
Overall, we feel All American Gutter Protection is a worthwhile provider if you’re looking for well-designed gutter guards that effectively block debris and prevent clogs.
All American Gutter Protection FAQ
What is All American Gutter Protection’s installation process?
During the installation process, All American Gutter Protection can install and service downspouts, inspect and replace rotten fascia boards, and install new seamless gutters if necessary. If not, they’ll install your gutter guards by attaching them behind the gutter’s drip edge to the fascia board. Afterward, they should clean up all the debris.
What colors are All American Gutter Protection’s gutters?
All American Gutter Protection offers more than 30 color options, allowing you to customize your gutters to fit your home’s aesthetic. You can compare color options by calling the company.
Do All American Gutter Protection’s gutter guards ever get clogged?
Any gutter guards can get clogged; however, All American Gutter Protection’s micro-mesh screen makes clogs within your gutters highly unlikely by blocking debris of various sizes. The rain and wind should keep most debris from accumulating on top of your gutter guard, but you can occasionally hose down or sweep over your gutters to eliminate the buildup of debris on your gutter guards.
Is All American Gutter Protection better than LeafFilter?
LeafFilter outscored All American Gutter Protection in our assessment, mainly due to its lifetime transferable warranty. All American Gutter Protection is on par with LeafFilter regarding product quality, overall flexibility, and reliability. Overall, both companies are dependable choices with high-quality gutter guards.
How We Chose the Top Gutter Guard Providers
We researched and analyzed dozens of gutter guards and gutter guard companies to create an in-depth review methodology. We formulated a rating system based on the factors homeowners find most important. We evaluated each provider’s gutter guard design and aesthetics, service offerings, customer service and communication, quote process, warranties, and financing options.
We created a separate rating system for DIY-installed gutter guards sold on retailer sites. We evaluated these guards based on their quality of materials, aesthetics, communication, warranty, customer reviews, and cost.
We evaluated each provider’s reputation using independent, third-party sites such as the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and Google My Business pages. For products, we analyzed the customer reviews on whichever online retailer primarily hosts the product.
