What Are The Best Gutter Guards? | 2024 Guide

By Alex Hawkins Updated September 17, 2024

Enter details in under 3 minutes

All products and services featured are independently selected by our editors. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The best gutter guards do more than prevent clogged gutters. They also help protect your roof, siding, and foundation from damage caused by clogs and water buildup, such as mold growth and roof rot. Proactive gutter protection prevents costly gutter maintenance in the future. We’ve researched gutter guard companies, analyzing products, customer reviews, and costs, and rated each provider against our rating system. We also installed and tested more than a dozen gutter guards to rate their performance, materials, and durability.

Our top gutter guard choices for professional installations are LeafFilter, and Leafguard, but there are several gutter guard companies to choose from depending on your needs. There are also DIY gutter guards such as Raptor, which can be appropriate for homeowners that prefer to install their own gutter guards. In this guide, we share our findings on our top five recommended gutter guard companies and explain what to consider before choosing the best gutter guard for your home.

Best Reverse-Curve
Leafguard
GET ESTIMATE

Best Gutter Guards of 2024

We spent more than 100 hours researching the gutter guard industry and months speaking to homeowners who purchased professional gutter guards within the last year. Based on the ranking factors we found were most important to consumers: services and features, reliability, cost and value, and flexibility, these are our top gutter guard company recommendations.


Detailed Summaries of Top Gutter Guard Companies

The following brands made our list because each offers quality gutter guards built to last. We put each provider through a rigorous review process that scored on factors such as debris blockage capabilities and warranty options. Then, we performed hands-on testing to determine how their products work, where they excel, and where they fall short. Read each provider’s breakdown to decide which is right for you.

LeafFilter

Best Overall
4.8

LeafFilter offers a three-piece, steel micro-mesh gutter guard system that uses surface tension to pull water through your gutters but prevent clogs and debris build-up with its gutter covers. Its steel body means that extreme temperature changes will not warp the guard over time. LeafFilter pitches the guard flush with your roof to minimize maintenance and visibility from the ground. LeafFilter’s gutters come in various colors, including off-white and beige, to match your home’s external color scheme.

Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Blocks materials as small as shingle grit and pollen
  • Can be cleaned with a leaf blower or light brushing
  • Doesn't overflow in downpours

Cons

  • Doesn't offer additional services outside of gutter guard installations
  • Has sales representatives with a reputation for pushy or aggressive sales tactics

LeafFilter Specs and Services

  • Gutter Cleaning Services
  • Gutter Sealing and Repair
  • Materials – Stainless Steel, Aluminum, uPVC Steel Micro-Mesh
  • Minimal Maintenance
  • New Gutter Installation
  • Steel Micro-Mesh Gutter Guard System
  • Temperature will Not Warp the Guards
  • Transferable Lifetime Warranty
  • Variety of Colors
  • Variety of Sizes

What Homeowners Are Saying

We analyzed the 100 most recent Google Reviews for LeafFilter’s Aurora, Colorado, branch. Some of these reviews were critical of the company’s professionalism and punctuality. Many homeowners noted that it took several phone calls to ensure they received services on the correct date. However, LeafFilter was responsive to each review.

Many reviews praised the quality of LeafFilter’s gutter guards, though some homeowners noted that LeafFilter’s guards are not ideal for extreme winter conditions. On its blog, The Leaflet, the company advises homeowners to take preventive measures to combat ice dams. You also have to clean your gutters every one to two years with LeafFilter’s gutter guards, despite advertising that you’ll never have to clean them again.

Leafguard

Best Reverse-Curve
3.8

Leafguard is a great option for homeowners looking for new gutters that include built-in protection against clogs. The reverse-curve design features a sturdy, one-piece construction that replaces your existing gutter system. The aluminum material resists warping and cracking and can endure the elements longer than many types of DIY gutter guards.
Leafguard customizes the length of each gutter run during professional installation for the perfect fit. It also uses a scratch-resistant finish and offers its gutter system in 12 or more colors.

Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Has an all-in-one system is a good deal for homeowners who need gutter replacements alongside their gutter guards
  • Possesses durable gutter helmet is impact resistant and highly durable
  • Uses a scratch-guard coating that allows it to better withstand corrosion, making long-lasting and weather-resistant

Cons

  • Has some of the highest prices in the industry, requiring a minimum of $7,800 for financing
  • Doesn't handle heavy water flow well and is not suitable for metal roofs or areas of heavy rainfall

Leafguard Specs and Services

  • 12 Color Options
  • 5 or 6-inch Size Options
  • Materials – Aluminum
  • Resists Warping and Cracking
  • Reverse Curve Gutter Guard System
  • Scratch Resistant Finish
  • Sturdy One-Piece Construction
  • Transferable Lifetime Warranty

What Homeowners Are Saying

We analyzed 100 reviews across Trustpilot and the BBB. Positive reviews mentioned professional and knowledgeable sales staff, clean and courteous installation, and a quality product. Discontented customers called out aggressive sales tactics, inflated prices, and limitations in the lifetime warranty.

Gutter Guards America

Best Customer Reviews
4.6

Gutter Guards America produces a corrosion-resistant micro-mesh gutter guard that will last for the life of your home covered by a transferable lifetime warranty. It features a seamless aluminum body and surgical-grade stainless steel mesh that prevents clogs from leaves, pests, and fine debris entering your gutters. Plastics, vinyl, and adhesives are absent from the construction, so you know your gutter guards won’t fail from abrupt seasonal changes. Installation is handled by professional contractors, providing you peace of mind that everything is in place and working correctly. Work crews also address issues with your existing gutters by cleaning, aligning, and re-sealing them as necessary.

Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Uses high-grade stainless steel in micro-mesh filter
  • Is manufactured in the USA
  • Offers a warranty on both manufacturing and installations

Cons

  • Reviews around poor post-installation communication
  • Small operating area

Gutter Guards America Specs and Services

  • 5 or 6-inch Size Options
  • Materials – Aluminum Body, and Stainless Steel Mesh
  • Micro-Mesh Gutter Guard System
  • There are no Plastics, Vinyl, or Adhesives
  • Transferable Lifetime Warrant

What Homeowners Are Saying

We found very positive reviews during our analysis of recent customer reviews across TrustPilot and the Better Business Bureau. Many of the reviews mentioned the professionalism and efficiency of the installation of the gutter guards. Other reviews indicated the transparency of the estimation process.

A few critical reviews stated that there was an issue with representatives from the company showing up at the appropriate time and receiving an efficient resolution to an install issue.

All American Gutter Protection

Best Customization Options
4.2

All American Gutter Protection provides a similar micro-mesh gutter guard system to LeafFilter, though All American’s design features an aluminum rather than uPVC frame. Its gutter guard is lightweight and resists warping and bending during large temperature fluctuations. The low-profile design minimizes visibility from the ground.

Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Offers more discounts than most other installers
  • Uses a reinforcing substructure for increased impact resistance
  • Incorporates a stainless steel micro-mesh screen with an aluminum frame

Cons

  • Doesn't offer cleaning or repair services
  • Has complaints pointing towards poor installation quality

All American Gutter Protection Specs and Services

  • 5, 6, or 7-inch Sizing Options
  • Fascia Replacement Available
  • Gutter and Downspout Installation
  • Low Profile Design
  • Materials – Aluminum Body, and Stainless Steel Mesh
  • Micro-Mesh Gutter Guard System
  • Resists Warping and Bending
  • Transferable Lifetime Warranty

What Homeowners Are Saying

We analyzed 100 Google Reviews across All American Gutter Protection branches in Atlanta; Nashville; Philadelphia; Greenville, South Carolina; and Ann Arbor, Michigan. Most customers praised the company for its effective installation and quality gutter guards.

There were noticeable complaints. Some reviews criticized All American Gutter Protection’s punctuality and scheduling. We recommend being somewhat flexible with your appointment time if you decide to use All American Gutter Protection.

HomeCraft

Best Add-On Services
4.4

HomeCraft Gutter Protection offers a marine-grade, stainless steel, micro-mesh gutter guard with raised diamonds throughout its cover. The guard also features a powder-coated aluminum frame that fits almost any gutter size. HomeCraft secures its gutter guard during installation by using hidden reinforced metal hangers attached to your fascia boards, keeping it secure in stormy conditions. The HomeCraft gutter guard sits flush with your gutter and has low visibility from the ground.

Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Has a stainless steel micro-mesh guard with a diamond pattern
  • Offers gutter installation, repair, and cleaning services
  • Provides a lifetime warranty on its installations

Cons

  • Has poor post installation communication
  • Doesn't provide pricing information online

HomeCraft Specs and Services

  • 5, or 6-inch Sizing Options
  • Gutter Cleaning
  • Gutter Installation
  • Gutter Repair
  • Low Visibility From the Ground
  • Materials – Stainless Steel and Aluminum Steel Micro-Mesh
  • Micro-Mesh Gutter Guard System
  • Transferable Lifetime Warranty
  • Uses Hidden Reinforced Metal Hangers

What Homeowners Are Saying

We found overwhelmingly positive reviews during our analysis of the 100 most recent Google Reviews for HomeCraft’s Charlotte, North Carolina, branch. Many of the reviews mentioned the company’s responsiveness and overall value. Many homeowners were also impressed with their quoted price and financing options.

The few critical reviews claimed that HomeCraft completed installation haphazardly, or that the quote process was frustrating.


Comparison of the Top Gutter Guard Companies

To help you compare options, we rated gutter guard companies based on factors such as the materials used, the upkeep required, and the warranty included. Then, we ranked each mover on a 100-point scale and converted those points into a star rating.

Company Star Rating Best For BBB Rating Link
4.8
Our Top Pick A+ GET ESTIMATE
3.8
Reverse Curve A+ GET ESTIMATE
4.4
Customer Reviews A+ GET ESTIMATE
4.2
Customization Options A GET ESTIMATE
4.2
Add-On Services B GET ESTIMATE

How We Chose the Top Gutter Guards

We researched and analyzed dozens of gutter guards and gutter guard companies to create an in-depth review methodology. We formulated a rating system based on the factors homeowners find most important. We evaluated each provider based on the following criteria:


Factors to Consider When Looking for Gutter Guards

When choosing the best gutter guard for your home, select one that is well-suited to your local climate and surrounding foliage. Consider your budget and how comfortable you are working on ladders. DIY guards can save money on labor costs, but you’ll need to install them yourself.

Types of Gutter Guards

There are many types of gutter guards to choose from. The longevity and benefits of these products are primarily determined by the guard’s material. Overall, stainless steel is the best material for guards, as it lasts the longest and is the most durable.

Gutter Guard MaterialBrands That Use These MaterialsProsConsLifespan
FoamGutterFoamEasy to install, malleable Degrades in UV rays, needs to be replaced most often1–2 years
PlasticAmerimax, FrostKingIncredibly cheap, easy to work with, easy to replaceWorst performance, easily breakable3–6 years
Powder Coated SteelAmerimaxEasy to install, low-cost for metalRusts when powder is damagedUp to 12 years (depending on climate) 
Stainless SteelLeafFilter, All American, Raptor, Waterlock Long-lasting, durable, corrosion resistantExpensive and often requires professional installationsUp to 20 years with proper care
AluminumLeafguard, WaterlockLight, corrosion-resistant, durableLess strong than steelUp to 20 years with proper care

Types of Gutter Guard Materials

Overall, stainless steel is the best material for gutter guards. It has the same longevity and similar corrosion resistance as aluminum but more durability. Other materials, such as foam inserts, plastic, and polyvinyl chloride (PVC), don’t last as long, are prone to breaking, and may not protect your gutters as reliably. 

MaterialAffordabilityDurability
Plastic$Low
Foam$$Low
Aluminum$$$Medium
Stainless Steel$$$$High

Gutter Guard Cost

The cost of a gutter guard installation can be divided into two categories: do-it-yourself (DIY) and professional. DIY guards will always be more cost-effective, but they lack the quality and warranties of professional installations. Professional projects are many times more expensive, with reverse-curve guards (such as those used by Leafguard) costing upward of $7,900.

Type Average Cost per Linear FootCost Range (200 linear feet)Average Cost (200 linear feet)*
Plastic screen (DIY)$.67–$1.50$135–$300$175
Foam (DIY)$1.49–$2$400–$650$550
Steel screen (DIY)$1.32–$1.76$264–$352$308
Brush (DIY)$3.60$700–$800$758
Micro-Mesh$27–$31$5,500–$6,300$5,900
Reverse-curve$20-$45$4,000–$10,000$7,900
*All cost data is via our 2024 survey of more than 1,000 gutter guards customers.

Warranties

A warranty provides additional security and peace of mind with your gutter guards. DIY gutter guards may have warranties that extend up to 25 years. Professional installation companies provide transferable lifetime warranties in most cases.

These warranties often have limitations, though. In particular, any tampering with the roof or structure around the guards will likely void your warranty.

Micro-Mesh vs Perforated Gutter Guards

Micro-mesh gutter guards have become the go-to premium gutter guard option. This type of gutter guard is made of a fine mesh that keeps debris out while allowing water to flow through into the gutter. A cheaper alternative is a perforated gutter guard, which is a solid surface with holes punched into it to allow water through. When purchasing gutter guards, homeowners need to decide which option is best for them.

Micro-mesh gutter guards are the more expensive option of the two, with perforated gutter guards sometimes costing as little has half the price of Micro-mesh gutter guards for the same home. However, Micro-mesh gutter guards allow water to pass through more easily than perforated solutions, and are less likely. In areas with frequent heavy rain, this makes Micro-mesh a great option, and the one we recommend for most homeowners. However, for some homeowners in areas with more infrequent heavy rain, perforated gutter guards can be an economical solution that doesn’t sacrifice too much in the way of performance.


What About DIY Gutter Guards?

It is possible for most homeowners to install gutter guards on their own. For skilled homeowners this could be a more economical option compared to professionally installed gutter guards, as an owner will likely pay less than half of what they would pay per 200 linear feet of gutter guards, but overall savings shouldn’t be assumed. DIY gutter guards tend to come with more limited warranties compared to professional installers, and any damage to your roof or gutters during installation would not be covered.

Additionally, DIY gutter costs don’t include any equipment needed for the installation. For owners confident in their installation skills, and who already own equipment, DIY gutter guards can be an affordable option. But for those who prefer the peace of mind of a professional installation and a more robust gutter guard warranty, professional gutter guard installation is a good choice.


What Are Good Qualities in a Gutter Guard? 3 Essential Traits

As we have mentioned, gutter guards are made from various materials and have many different designs. However, not all gutter guards are created equal. We’ve detailed the qualities that make a gutter guard effective and long-lasting so you can find the best solution for your home.

Durable Materials

The best gutter guards are made from strong, durable, and corrosion-resistant materials in order to withstand harsh weather conditions and large debris. Gutter guards made from stainless steel, aluminum, and uPVC hold up best in harsh conditions.

Effective Design

A good gutter guard should be designed to allow water to flow freely through your gutters while blocking leaves and other debris to prevent clogs. The best gutter guards block large materials, such as leaves, as well as small debris that can build up over time, such as shingle grit and pollen. The guards should also have a gentle slope that pushes water and plant-matter buildup off to the ground. Micro-mesh and reverse-curve gutter guards best meet these requirements.

Secure Installation

An effective gutter guard must be installed securely and without damaging your existing gutters. You can’t securely fasten plastic, foam, or brush gutter guards to your gutters, so while these may work as a temporary DIY solution, they won’t be effective long-term. Professional installation companies attach their gutter guards to your gutters with metal screws, ensuring a stable, long-lasting product.


Our Recommendation for the Top Gutter Guards

Our research and firsthand testing showed that micro-mesh guards are the most effective overall. These guards filtered out the most debris (more than 90% in some cases) and allowed water to pass through to the gutters easily. This allows them to handle heavy rain well, and keep your gutters clear even during severe storm periods. Stainless steel and aluminum perform the best, last the longest, and offer corrosion resistance. Aluminum gutter guards are also less noticeable than many other materials, which is ideal for people looking for a discrete gutter guard solution.

Professional gutter guard installation leaves the work in the hands of a specialist. We recommend LeafFilter for its comprehensive service, high-quality materials, efficient design, and outstanding customer reviews. LeafFilter’s screen uses a 275-micron stainless steel mesh that blocks even the smallest materials, such as pine needles, seedpods, shingle grit and pollen.


Gutter Guard FAQ

What style of gutter guards works best with heavy leaves?

Micro-mesh, mesh, surface tension, and screen gutter guards block leaves and push them off your gutters. Because leaves are large and are blocked by most gutter guard styles, focus more on the guard’s construction and build quality when shopping. Steel is one of the strongest gutter guard materials. Some gutter guards also have hangers to support the mesh screen or the gutter itself.

Which gutter guards work best in snow and ice?

Any gutter guard with a heating element is best for snow and ice. Without this, ice dams may form inside your gutters, as well as dangerous icicles. Heated gutter guards typically feature a cable running through them, dispersing heat to prevent liquid from freezing. If you encounter seasonal ice and snow, you will also encounter sharp temperature changes. Metal gutter guards are best for this application because they won’t warp or crack like less durable vinyl or plastic construction. Aluminum and stainless steel have the added benefit of inherent corrosion resistance, but powder-coated or painted steel can work too.

Are gutter guards effective?

While no gutter guard keeps gutters completely free of debris, they drastically reduce how often homeowners need to clean their gutters. The effectiveness of gutter guards varies by style. Temporary solutions such as foam and brush guards are less effective than high-end options such as reverse-curve and micro-mesh.

How do I clean gutters with gutter guards?

Your strategy for cleaning gutters with gutter guards will depend on the type of gutter guard you have installed. Brush and foam gutter guards are easily removable, allowing you to clean the gutter as normal. Snap-in gutter guards can also be removed easily for cleaning, but for gutter guards installed professionally with hardware, you may need to contact your gutter guard provider for instructions. 

How do I measure for gutter guards?

Homes commonly use K-style gutters. To measure the width, place your tape measure on the gutter edge that touches your roof and extend it to the outside face of the gutter. The most common size for gutters in the United States is 5 inches in width, but homes in rainier regions may require 6- or even 7-inch systems. This measurement is the size you will need for your gutter guard. 

What are ice dams?

An ice dam forms when snow and ice go through cycles of thawing and refreezing. This process can trap meltwater on your roof behind refrozen ice, potentially causing leaks. A clean and undamaged gutter guard should not contribute to the development of an ice dam. However, if you live in an area prone to harsh winter weather, you should routinely check your gutters for signs of ice damming.

Is a plastic gutter screen a good option for my home?

Plastic gutter screens can be effective at filtering debris from your gutter system for a period of time but come with many pitfalls. Namely, this material does not hold up well to extended sun exposure and breaks down more quickly than aluminum or steel gutter guards.