Leafguard Gutters Review | 2024
All products and services featured are independently selected by our editors. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission.
If you’re looking to replace your current gutter system and want the convenience of installing gutter guards simultaneously, consider Leafguard. When our team compared gutter guard providers using a robust rating system, the company stood out for its self-cleaning, corrosion-resistant product. We were especially impressed with Leafguard’s ScratchGuard® paint finish, which enables its gutter guards to better withstand scratches, chips, peeling, and more to help maintain your home’s aesthetic as much as possible.
In evaluating gutter guard installers, we crafted a methodology to help us compare some of the top gutter guard brands and determine which are the best and why. We ranked companies on various factors, including materials and gutter guard types, debris blockage capabilities, company reputation, and warranties. Our full Leafguard review offers key insights to determine if the company suits your home’s needs.
Our Review of Leafguard
- Material: Aluminum
- Style: Helmet/reverse-curve
- Durability: Impact-, rust-, weather-, and corrosion-resistant
- Debris Blockage: Leaves, pine needles, seedpods, and twigs
Leafguard’s all-in-one system is a great option if you’re looking to install or replace your gutters and add gutter guards simultaneously, as the guards come already attached. While this may be a downside for those who are happy with their current gutters and are only looking to install guards, it adds convenience if you’re looking for both. It’s especially great if you prefer a completely new gutter protection system requiring minimal maintenance.
Like the other gutter guards we examined, Leafguard’s system is corrosion-resistant, weather-resistant, and self-cleaning, meaning it’ll always look and function its best. Leafguard really stands out for its ScratchGuard® paint finish that assures the whole system, including the gutters and the guards, remains chip, crack, peel, rot, and rust-free, which can be a common issue in other systems. Unlike a competitor such as All American Gutter Protection, Leafguard’s system is also backed by an impressive transferable limited lifetime warranty, which covers the entire cost of repairing, repainting, or replacing any system proven defective from normal wear and tear.
These perks do come at a cost, however, as Leafguard has some of the highest prices in the industry, especially when compared to a company like All American Gutter Protection, which offers more value than other installers. That said, the higher price can be justified because the Leafguard product comprises both the gutter and the guard. So, as far as cost is concerned, it’s not necessarily an apples-to-apples comparison of offerings when looking at it against the other products we reviewed, which are all strictly guards. With Leafguard, you’re paying more because you’re getting more.
It’s important to note that there are better choices than this system for homeowners in particularly rainy areas such as Florida, Louisiana, or Washington, as we found it doesn’t handle heavy rain very well. In those areas, you might be better off with a company like LeafFilter, which we found performs wonderfully in downpour conditions.
Specs
Leafguard’s unique one-piece design stands out from most other gutter guards. The company uses materials and processes that exceed industry standards to guarantee high functionality and durability.
Gutter Guard Screen
- Proprietary reverse-curve design keeps most pine needles, fir needles, leaves, and many other types of debris out of gutters
Gutter Guard Frame
- Custom-fit on-site
- ScratchGuard® paint finish is resistant to scratches, chips, erosion, and rust
- Made from aluminum that’s 20% thicker than the industry standard
Gutter Guard Hangers
- One-piece design
- Supported every 2 feet, which is twice the industry standard
Maintenance
The company website states that the system is not only maintenance-free but never needs cleaning. Additionally, the system is coated in Leafguard’s ScratchGuard® paint finish, which helps ensure it remains visibly top-notch, as it’s chip-, crack-, rot-, peel-, and rust-resistant. To top it all off, the company backs its systems with a no-clog guarantee, which means it will send out a technician to clear your gutters if they clog.
Pros
- Its all-in-one system is ideal for those looking to replace both their gutters and guards
- Durable, impact-resistant gutter helmet
- Efficient, self-cleaning system
- Lifetime transferable warranty
- Scratch- and corrosion-resistant coating
Cons
- Has some of the highest prices in the industry
- Incompatible with homes that have metal roofs
- Not suitable for homes that experience significant water runoff
How We Rated Leafguard
According to our rating system and methodology, Leafguard earned 3.8 out of 5 stars. We scored companies based on the following factors:
- Services and features: This included reviewing the materials used and types of gutter guards available, the level and kind of debris blockage, and any noteworthy additional features offered by the product or company.
- Reliability: We evaluated reputation, experience level, and expertise.
- Cost and value: This considered overall pricing for products and services, any discounts or promotions offered, and warranty information.
- Flexibility: Our team examined customer support offerings, the general upkeep required of the products, and the ease of installation.
Read on to learn more about Leafguard’s performance in each area and how it stacks up against competitors.
Services and Features
When scoring for services and features, we looked at materials and gutter guard types offered, the type and amount of debris blockage, and other notable features or offerings of the product or company, such as a low-profile design and gutter cleaning.
Leafguard scored 3.1 out of 5 stars for its services and features. We loved that the company makes its all-in-one systems in America from corrosion-resistant aluminum. Aluminum gutters are notoriously durable, and Leafguard’s aluminum gutters are no exception. While we were impressed by the variety of debris these gutter guards can filter out, including pine needles, leaves, seedpods, and even twigs, these particular gutter guards can’t filter out shingle grit, while many other competing products can.
Leafguard’s system uses a reverse-curve design that may not be as low-profile as some competitors’ offerings, but the one-piece structure, where the gutter guard comes attached to the gutter, makes it extremely sturdy and reliable. The company will also create a custom system for your specific home, offering a perfect, streamlined fit.
Reliability
When determining reliability, we looked at the company’s overall reputation, number of years of experience, and employees’ expertise, including whether they’re bonded and do installations in-house.
Leafguard earned an impressive 5 out of 5 stars in the reliability category. The Leafguard gutter and guard system first became available in 1993, making it over 30 years old and a well-established brand and product within the space. The company’s reliability is further backed by an impressive award archive proudly displayed on its website.
We found that all gutter guard system installations are performed by trusted and bonded Leafguard in-house experts. This is notable because competitors such as LeafFilter, All American Gutter Protection, and HomeCraft don’t use in-house employees, which can lead to customer service issues. Finally, Leafguard is available in more than 35 states, which is more than many others in the industry.
Cost and Value
When evaluating a company’s cost and value, we looked at the price of its products and services, whether any discounts or promotions are offered, and the length and transferability of warranties.
The company scored 4.2 out of 5 stars for cost and value. As previously mentioned, Leafguard products are some of the most expensive in the industry. Still, the price certainly has some perks, including a robust warranty and a 100% money-back guarantee. This emphasizes the company’s belief in its product functionality and longevity.
If anything were to happen, and your system was damaged due to manufacturing defects or normal wear and tear—and it needed to be repaired or replaced—Leafguard’s transferable lifetime finish warranty would cover it. We also appreciated that the company’s warranty information is clearly laid out and thoroughly explained on its website in an easy-to-find place.
While the company occasionally offers discounts and promotions, it doesn’t offer senior or military discounts, unlike others in the industry that provide these permanent perks.
Flexibility
When rating for flexibility, we looked at customer support options, upkeep required, ease of installation, and the system’s ability to be installed on existing gutters.
Leafguard earned a 3.2 out of 5-star rating for flexibility. Unfortunately, of all the other gutter guard companies we scored, Leafguard was the only one that didn’t earn a perfect 5 out of 5 score in this category. This is mainly because the Leafguard system can’t be installed on top of existing gutters, as it’s an all-in-one design. While this is great if you desire gutter guards and want to replace your current gutters, it automatically eliminates those who are already happy with their system.
That said, if an all-in-one system does fit your needs, the company offers a photo gallery on its website. This is a great tool if you’re concerned with what your home will look like after the installation.
If you’re looking for an all-in-one system that offers easy upkeep, Leafguard is an excellent option. We love that it’s self-cleaning and includes a built-in pitch to catch debris roll-off.
Compare Leafguard to Other Gutter Protection Companies
Leafguard stands out among competitors for its expertise, with trained, in-house employees performing all its installations. However, it falls short because you can’t install the system on existing gutters.
| Company | Logo | Star Rating | BBB Rating | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 | A+ | VISIT SITE | ||
 | A+ | VISIT SITE | ||
 | A+ | VISIT SITE | ||
 | A | VISIT SITE | ||
 | B | VISIT SITE |
Leafguard Reviews
With around 650 customer reviews across Google, Yelp, Trustpilot, and the Better Business Bureau (BBB), Leafguard is generally less reviewed than most of its closest competitors. We saw some common themes in the available reviews. Our team found numerous mentions of Leafguard’s helpful and knowledgeable representatives; however, there were also reviews regarding pushy and aggressive sales tactics. Others mentioned the “no-clog” guarantee as misleading, as they did experience clogs, while others said they were pleased with the warranty follow-through.
We chose these reviews because they represent the positive and negative experiences that both long- and short-term customers of Leafguard have experienced. Gary and Judith’s reviews showed that the company is good about following through on its promises and guarantees to maintain and clean your system should it become clogged. However, the experiences of Don and Takoda—dealing with unresponsive reps—was a sentiment many other reviewers echoed.
Breakdown by Review Site
We examined reviews for Leafguard on the BBB, Trustpilot, and Google Reviews to get a general understanding of what customers had to say about the company. Here’s what we found:
- Better Business Bureau: Leafguard has a 1.47 out of 5-star rating on its BBB profile. Despite its low star rating, the company is accredited and still maintains an A+. While Leafguard replies to some reviews, the majority have no response.
- Trustpilot: Leafguard has a poor 2.2 out of 5-star rating from Trustpilot. The company isn’t “verified” by Trustpilot, and it hasn’t responded to anything.
- Google Reviews: Leafguard is well-rated on Google Reviews, earning an impressive 4.6 out of 5 stars. The company replies to most reviews, and we saw that it often responds to negative comments with the direct customer service phone number to connect customers with someone who can help resolve their issues.
*All review scores were accurate when published.
Are Leafguard Gutters Worth It?
Leafguard is worth it if you want new gutters with gutter guards and a low-maintenance system that will enable you to worry less about upkeep.
With 20% thicker aluminum and liquid adhesion technology, Leafguard has created an effective one-piece gutter and gutter guard combination that protects against leaves, pests, sediment, water, and other debris.
Additionally, Leafguard’s unique and sturdy one-piece design makes it highly durable. Because it’s a single, seamless unit, you don’t have to worry about the water leaking through and leading to sagging gutters.
Not only does the company guarantee the product’s functionality, but with its ScratchGuard® paint finish, it will maintain its aesthetic appeal as well, as it’s made not to crack, peel, chip, rot, or rust.
Unless you aren’t looking to install new gutters in addition to guards, or if you live in an area that receives hefty rainfall, Leafguard is worth considering. However, if you are happy with the condition of your current gutters and would just like a gutter guard attached to them, then we recommend LeafFilter as the best option for professional installation.
Leafguard FAQ
What size are Leafguard gutters?
Most Leafguard residential gutter systems come in two sizes: five and six inches.
What style of gutter guards works best with heavy leaves?
Micro-mesh, mesh, surface tension, and screen gutter guards block heavy leaves and drive them off your gutters.
Do Leafguard gutter guards keep out pine needles?
Yes, Leafguard’s gutter system keeps out pine needles and other common debris.
Does Leafguard work on steep roofs?
Yes. Leafguard custom-fits its gutter system to each home’s roof pitch, so the company can make its guards fit even steep roofs.
What is Leafguard’s installation process?
The Leafguard installation process begins with a free estimate from a licensed, professional gutter installer. The pro thoroughly assesses your current gutter systems, determines any issues, and explains how the Leafguard system would work for your home. They’ll then give you an estimate right on the spot.
Then, the installation process can begin, which usually takes a day at most. They’ll start by removing and properly disposing of your current gutters. Since each Leafguard system is custom-formed and fit per home, creating yours is the next step, which will be done on-site at your home with a roll-forming machine.
From there, the installers determined the proper pitch for the systems to maximize water flow and finish installing the gutter system.
What colors are Leafguard’s gutters?
There are 12 different color swatches featured on Leafguard’s website in varying shades of white, cream, tan, gray, and brown.
Do Leafguard’s gutter guards ever get clogged?
If your gutters clog when you own your home, Leafguard promises to clean the whole system for free. Like other companies, Leafguard’s products are backed by a no-clog guarantee.
Is Leafguard better than LeafFilter?
Based on our rating system, Leafguard scored 3.8 out of 5 stars, while LeafFilter scored 4.8 out of 5 stars. While LeafFilter is a better company based on our scoring, the best gutter guard company for you will depend on various factors, such as location, budget, and more.
How We Chose the Top Gutter Guard Providers
We researched and analyzed dozens of gutter guards and gutter guard companies to create an in-depth review methodology. We formulated a rating system based on the factors homeowners find most important. We evaluated each provider’s gutter guard design and aesthetics, service offerings, customer service and communication, quote process, warranties, and financing options.
We created a separate rating system for DIY-installed gutter guards sold on retailer sites. We evaluated these guards based on their quality of materials, aesthetics, communication, warranty, customer reviews, and cost.
We evaluated each provider’s reputation using independent, third-party sites such as the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and Google My Business pages. For products, we analyzed the customer reviews on whichever online retailer primarily hosts the product.
