Pella vs. Andersen | 2024 Comparison

By Alex Hawkins Updated June 24, 2024

Get Estimate

Enter details in under 3 minutes

All products and services featured are independently selected by our editors. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Pella and Andersen share long histories and strong reputations in the window industry. They’re both available in all 50 states, offer windows and doors, and have been in business since the early 1900s. But their materials, warranties, and prices slightly differ.

We’ve dug into both brands’ warranties and customer feedback to provide an unbiased review of two of the country’s best window brands. Read on to learn more.

Pella vs. Andersen: How Do They Compare?

Compare Pella and Andersen based on key factors below.

Fast FactsPellaAndersen
State Availability5050
Warranty OptionsLimited warrantiesLimited warranties
Price Range$450–$2,000$350–$3,500
Product OfferingsWindows and doorsWindows and doors
MaterialsVinyl, wood, and fiberglassWood and Fibrex

Pella vs. Andersen: Pros, Cons, and Customer Reviews

Pros and Cons

Pella Pros and Cons

Pella Windows uses eco-friendly materials and has an excellent guarantee, but its availability is limited.


  • Offers wood, vinyl, and fiberglass window frame options
  • Includes the Pella Care Guarantee if you purchase from a showroom
  • Provides eco-friendly materials with Energy Star certification


  • Limits product availability to showrooms, Pella dealers, and Lowe’s
  • Varies warranty options based on window material and series

Andersen Pros and Cons

Andersen Windows has a broad selection of high-quality products but is more expensive than other brands.


  • Has one of the most comprehensive selections of window products
  • Offers eco-friendly Fibrex material
  • Includes various warranties between 10 and 20 years


  • Charges a premium price
  • Doesn’t disclose much cost information online

Customer Reviews

Pella Reviews

We analyzed the 100 most recent Google Reviews for Pella’s Austin, Texas, location and found that 75% of the reviews were more than three stars. Most reviews praised the company for its beautiful, durable windows and professional employees. Critical reviews mention long wait times and installation delays. 

Read what Pella customers had to say about the company below: 

So excited, thanks pella

We replaced the windows in our 1930s bungalow, and they are AWESOME! They all OPEN! I can now make my tiny home into a giant [screened-in] porch. So excited for the first cool breeze. Thanks, Pella!
Cheryl Drown via Google Reviews

Detail Oriented

After a severe rainstorm, no leaks! We ordered a side patio door and French doors, both with transoms. For the replacement of old doors, I was concerned about the outside trim work, which would affect the stone masonry. However, not to worry because… Kyle, the installer, did a fabulous job! He was detail-oriented; he sealed gaps, cut and stained the trim, and secured the fit of our doors. Finally, a company that does what it says and more than met my expectations. I would recommend Pella. Read more
Sandy Dunaway via Google Reviews

We were excited

We were excited to replace [our] back door in May 2021, but after 10 months of the salesperson not putting in the order and the [installation] getting pushed back 4 times for 2 months, we’re over it. We still haven’t had the service completed.
Jeremy Miller via Google Reviews

Andersen Reviews

We analyzed reviews for Renewal by Andersen to get a sense of the company’s overall customer service. We found 89% of the Google Reviews for Renewal by Andersen’s San Diego location were favorable. Customers loved the company’s quick response time and quality workmanship. However, some reviews mention spam calling and high estimates. 

Here’s what some Renewal by Andersen customers said about their experiences: 

Completed ahead of schedule

It was a great surprise when Renewal by Andersen [said] that my windows and doors were ready for installation, as I was not expecting them to arrive for another two months. … The installation was estimated for three days but was completed ahead of… schedule (done in one long day). We are very grateful for their work approach and cleaning up at the end of the day. Read more
Blanca Shriner via google reviews

Well-trained and professional

Over the past three years, we have used Renewal by Andersen to replace all of the windows in our home plus three French doors. Their work crews are well-trained, professional, and courteous. … They prep the areas and get right to work. They… respond quickly to any problems or concerns. Read more
Lee Ledford via google reviews

no quotes over the phone or email

I called Renewal by Andersen, and they said someone needed to come in to do a quote and they couldn’t do it by email or over the phone. So I said OK. I had a couple of quotes beforehand for $2,500 and $3,500. Renewal by Andersen quoted $18,000 for… a patio door. My contractor just told me to buy the door at Home Depot [for] $900, and they will install it for $700. Read more
Alex ozols via google reviews

Pella vs. Andersen: Company Comparison

Company History

Andersen and Pella have longer histories than most brands in the windows industry, offering extensive knowledge and expertise. 

Pella Company History

Pella founder Peter Kuyper started the company in 1925. He bought and merged a small window screen company with his family’s lumber business and began producing high-quality windows and doors. Since then, the Iowa-based manufacturer has expanded to more than 8,000 employees and has become one of the most recognizable window brands. Its Pella Design Centers are in Lowe’s Home Improvement stores nationwide

Andersen Company History

Danish immigrant Hans Andersen founded the Andersen Corporation in 1903. The Bayport, Minnesota-based manufacturer is now an international company with more than 12,000 employees and four brands: Andersen Windows, Renewal by Andersen, MQ Luxury Windows and Doors, and EMCO Storm and Screen Doors.

You can find Andersen Windows at Home Depot stores throughout the United States. We recommend Renewal by Andersen for specialized white-glove window replacement and new construction services.

Available Products

Pella and Andersen offer a wide range of windows, from standard single-hung windows to elegant bay windows. Learn more about both brands’ offerings below.

Pella Products

Here are the different types of windows Pella offers:

  • Awning windows
  • Bay windows
  • Bow windows
  • Casement windows
  • Custom options
  • Double-hung windows
  • Picture windows
  • Single-hung windows
  • Sliding window
  • Specialty windows

Pella offers various window lines. Its Architect series and Lifestyle series both offer high-quality wooden windows with detailed window frames and grille profiles for a traditional, timeless look. 

If wood frame windows aren’t your style, Pella offers minimalist, fiberglass windows through its Impervia series. Most of Pella’s products meet Energy Star certification. The company offers energy-efficient windows with Low-E insulating coats. It also works with wood vendors who practice responsible harvest and replenishment.

Andersen Products

Below are the various types of windows Andersen offers: 

  • Awning windows
  • Bay windows
  • Bow windows
  • Casement windows
  • Double-hung windows
  • Gliding windows
  • Pass-through windows
  • Picture windows
  • Single-hung windows
  • Specialty windows

Andersen offers many product lines. Its A-series includes high-end architectural windows with wooden cores and vinyl, fiberglass, or composite cladding (the outer layer of material). These materials are responsibly sourced, making this series Andersen‘s most energy-efficient line.

The company’s E-series line offers more elegant windows with wooden cores and aluminum cladding. These windows come in more than 50 colors and finishes. 

Andersen’s 100, 200, and 400 series provide more standard and economical window options. These lines use the company’s proprietary Fibrex material, made of 40% recycled Ponderosa pine wood and 60% polyvinyl chloride (PVC). These windows are simple, cost-effective, and eco-friendly.

Pricing Information

Both companies offer a wide range of products at various price points. 

Pella Pricing

Pella offers some pricing information online, but you may receive a different quote during your consultation depending on your location and project scope. Pella’s wood windows are the most expensive, costing $530 to $1,750. This is because wood windows require more labor and materials. Pella’s fiberglass windows are more cost-effective at $560 to $800. The company’s vinyl windows are $250 to $1,100 depending on the window style and customization.

Andersen Pricing

Andersen doesn’t provide many cost details online, with most of its windows requiring you to request a quote. Based on our requested quotes, its 100 series is the most cost-effective option, ranging between $350 and $600. Its 200 and 400 series are $600 to $1,500. Andersen’s architectural A-series and E-series are pricier at $1,250 to $2,300 due to their complexity and high-quality materials.

Pella vs. Andersen: Warranty Options

Pella and Andersen offer various limited warranties on different products. These warranties cover issues that might occur within the first few years of ownership and ensure top-quality installation.

Pella Warranty Options

Pella includes a different warranty for each product. Most of its windows include a transferable 10-year limited warranty for hardware and a two-year limited warranty for labor. You also receive the Pella Care Guarantee if you purchase your Pella windows from a local Pella Window and Door Showroom. This guarantee covers faulty installation, product failure, or damage.

Pella’s website lists the warranty options for each product.

Andersen Warranty Options

Andersen also offers varying warranties for each product. For example, its E-Series products include a 20-year warranty for manufacturing, material, and workmanship defects. All products include the company’s two-year Owner-2-Owner limited warranty covering manufacturing, material, and workmanship defects. 

Andersen’s website lists the warranty options for each product.

Our Recommendation

Both Pella and Andersen offer stylish, durable, and high-quality products. Andersen has a broader selection of windows, from the Andersen 100 series’ simple vinyl windows to the Architectural series’ elegant, wood-framed windows. Easy access to the company’s massive window and door selection may also speed up your installation. 

Those interested in eco-friendly materials should consider Pella, as it uses sustainable sources and works with wood vendors who practice responsible harvest and replenishment. Most Pella windows and doors meet Energy Star performance guidelines and have a Low-E insulating coat.

Use our tool below to see if Pella or Andersen service your address and find other reputable window installation companies in the area.

Get Estimates From Local Window Installers Near You
Just answer a few questions, and we’ll take care of the rest!

Pella vs. Andersen FAQ

Who is more expensive, Pella or Andersen?

Andersen is more expensive than Pella. Andersen is a luxury brand with an extensive history in the windows industry, resulting in higher prices. 

Are Pella windows made in the United States?

Yes, Pella windows are made in the United States in Pella, Iowa.

Do Andersen windows increase home value?

Yes, Andersen windows increase home value. Installing replacement windows always increases home value because it upgrades your home. Installing Andersen windows may increase your home value more than other brands because of the company’s name and reputation.

Can you paint Andersen Fibrex windows?

Yes, you can sand and paint Andersen’s Fibrex windows to match your exterior or interior color.  Andersen offers further customization for its Fibrex windows by providing your choice of hardware and grille pattern.

How We Chose the Top Window Brands

We researched and analyzed dozens of window manufacturers. We then crafted a rating system based on each brand’s standard and energy-efficient product offerings.

We spoke directly to representatives at each company to learn how the installation process works and determine how each brand personalizes its windows for each home. We also closely analyzed each company’s warranty options to ensure their product and labor guarantees match or exceed industry standards. 

Finally, we assessed the manufacturer’s years of experience and customer reputation. In addition, we analyzed the 100 most recent Google Reviews for each provider across various locations and branches.