Renewal By Andersen Review | 2025 Guide
All products and services featured are independently selected by our editors. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission.
According to our in-depth rating system and methodology, Renewal by Andersen is the top-rated window brand. It stood out for its high-quality frames that retain their shape and strength across temperature extremes and its energy-efficient glass options, which enable you to reduce heating and cooling costs while letting in plentiful natural light.
We compared Renewal by Andersen and 15 other window providers to determine which was the best in the industry. In addition to evaluating the quality and variety of each company’s replacement windows, our team looked at their reliability, value, and ability to address customer needs. In this review, we cover the many reasons you should consider Renewal by Andersen and a few reasons you shouldn’t.
Get Estimates From Local Window Experts
Just answer a few questions, and we'll take care of the rest.
Window Replacement Cost
Replacement windows on average range from $300 to $1,200.
Single-Hung Windows
Single-hung windows on average cost $150 to $400 per window.
Energy Efficient Upgrades
Double-pane installation typically ranges from $450 to $1,000 per window.
Our Summary and Review of Renewal by Andersen
- Year Founded: 1995
- State availability: 50
- Warranty options: Transferable limited warranty
- Price range: $300–$1,800* per window
*Cost data via our 2024 survey of 1,500 homeowners.
One of our favorite features of Renewal by Andersen’s windows is its patented frame material, Fibrex. We contacted the company to learn more about its impressive composite and what differentiates it from traditional window frame materials.
Its team informed us that Fibrex offers the best qualities of wood and vinyl while avoiding those materials’ pitfalls. Like wood, Fibrex is exceptionally durable, but it isn’t susceptible to rot despite being made up of 40% wood fibers. We also learned that Fibrex is low maintenance, similar to vinyl. Unlike vinyl, however, Fibrex maintains its strength across large temperature fluctuations. Usually, vinyl expands in high heat and becomes brittle in cold temperatures, jeopardizing its structural integrity.
We also like the multiple glass coating options available at Renewal by Anderson. Its High-Performance Low-E4 glass blocks 84% of harmful UV rays, which helps reduce heating and cooling costs and prevents sun-damaged furniture. If your area stays warm most of the year, the High-Performance Low-E4 Sun Glass is a better option, as it blocks 95% of UV rays. The company offers additional glass options for dry, high-heat environments and cooler locales.
Despite Fibrex’s benefits, the company does itself a disservice by not offering other frame material options. Depending on your environment and priorities, Fibrex may only provide marginal benefits. With a lower-cost frame option such as vinyl, more homeowners could take advantage of the company’s energy-efficient windows.
Pros
- Composite frame offers the durability of wood with vinyl’s low maintenance
- ENERGY STAR certification highlights window efficiency and potential energy savings
- In-house installation team ensures consistent workmanship
- Warranty terms are published on the website to prevent confusion about coverage
- Many available window types and color combinations for frame and hardware to fit most homes across various architectural styles
Cons
- Only offers high-grade frames limiting accessibility to budget-conscious homeowners
- Customer reviews mention a slow pace from initial sale to installation
Our Detailed Rating of Renewal by Andersen
According to our scoring system, Renewal by Andersen earned an impressive 4.6 out of 5 stars. We rated each company based on various criteria across four general categories:
- Services and features: This looked at the types of windows offered and the materials used for the glass and frame. We also awarded points for extra features, such as triple-pane windows.
- Reliability: Companies earned points in this category for positive customer ratings, maintaining industry certifications, and each company’s overall experience.
- Cost and value: We determined this score by reviewing each company’s warranty, discounts and promotions, and financing options.
- Flexibility: Our team considered the types of customer support, online features, and whether a company offered additional home services.
Services and Features
When scoring for services and features, we considered the types of windows offered, their construction, and the availability of extra features.
Renewal by Andersen earned 4.4 out of 5 stars for the services and features category. It lags behind competitors that offer a more comprehensive selection of window types and frames. Unlike Pella and Window World, Renewal by Andersen doesn’t offer single-hung windows, which could require some homeowners to use multiple window companies or change the type of windows in their home when completing replacements. However, it manufactures nearly every kind of window its competitors offer, which should satisfy most homeowners’ needs.
Additionally, Renewal by Andersen only offers its high-quality composite window frame. While it’s notable for its durability, low maintenance, and insulating ability, you may prefer to save money and opt for a mid-quality frame such as those offered by Pella. With the exception of Marvin Windows, which has a full suite of frames, most of the companies we reviewed only offer one or two types.
Reliability
We examined a company’s reputation, experience, and customer satisfaction when assessing reliability.
Renewal by Andersen scored a perfect 5 out of 5 stars for reliability. Window World and Castle Windows also earned perfect scores in this category. Like most competitors, Renewal by Andersen maintains certifications from ENERGY STAR and the National Fenestration Rating Council (NFRC) for its energy-efficient products. These ratings can help you choose the best window for your climate that maximizes natural light without incurring extra costs for energy consumption.
Renewal by Andersen also stands out in this category for its more favorable Better Business Bureau (BBB) customer ratings, which show that most are satisfied with their experience with the company. Additionally, it only uses in-house employees for installation, which helps maintain consistent quality standards nationwide. Pella’s BBB customer ratings lag behind Renewal by Anderson, and it also outsources some of its installations.
Champion Windows, which isn’t BBB accredited, also has a lower customer rating with the agency. An alert on the BBB page for its headquarters mentions a pattern of customer complaints detailing product defects and long wait times for installations and return phone calls.
Cost and Value
We scored cost and value by looking at return on investment, discounts and promotions, and warranty terms.
Renewal by Andersen scored 4.5 out of 5 stars in the cost and value category. We like that it offers a transferable warranty, giving the company an edge over Champion. This is especially beneficial if you sell your home because the warranty coverage will transfer to the new owner. Additionally, Renewal by Andersen’s warranty covers workmanship, which is absent from Pella’s warranty.
The company lost points because it offers a limited warranty that covers hardware for 10 years, glass for 20 years, and workmanship for two. Limited warranties are fairly standard among our highest-rated window companies, although Castle, Window Nation, and a few other providers provide lifetime coverage.
Other notable features in this category are the company’s in-house financing, which can streamline the purchasing process, and its ongoing promotions, which can lessen the financial burden of replacing windows. At the time of publication, it offered a 40% discount for additional windows with 0% financing and $0 down.
Flexibility
When scoring for flexibility, we looked at customer support options, convenience features, and the availability of additional home improvement services.
Renewal by Andersen received its lowest score in the flexibility category–4.3 out of 5 stars. Similar to competitors, it provides weekend customer support and online maintenance guides. This offers multiple avenues to find answers to your questions when it’s most convenient for you. The company also has an online service request form, which is perfect when you need a technician to visit but don’t have the time or desire to speak on the phone.
Renewal by Andersen lost points for its lack of an online chat feature, which Pella and Champion offer. This comes in handy when talking on the phone is inconvenient, but you still need real-time assistance from a company representative. Renewal by Andersen also fell short of its competitors here because of its limited set of additional services. If you need siding work done in addition to window replacement, you may prefer Champion or Window World for the additional convenience of dealing with one less contractor. Otherwise, this shouldn’t impact your decision.
Renewal by Andersen Product Overview
Renewal by Andersen offers some of the most popular types of windows, including double-hung, casement, and picture windows. Its composite frame material provides enhanced durability, while its variety of glass materials allows you to fine-tune your window’s thermal protection for your climate.
Types of Windows
- Awning
- Bay/bow
- Casement
- Double-hung
- Picture
- Sliding/gliding
- Specialty (arched, circular, pentagon)
Frame Materials
- Composite
Glass Materials
- Tinted glass
- Low-e glass coating
Renewal by Andersen Products We Recommend
We’re particularly impressed with Renewal by Andersen’s Acclaim double-hung window because of its practicality, durability, and versatility. Both sashes open and tilt, facilitating improved ventilation and easy cleaning. Its frame uses the same resilient Fibrex composite as the company’s other windows, ensuring longevity, while its mortise and tenon construction provides an elegant hand-made appearance. The double-hung window also features high-quality weather stripping to eliminate drafts and maintain a water-tight seal.
Renewal by Andersen’s Buying and Installation Process
Here’s a quick rundown of the company’s buying and installation process:
- To start the process, contact your local Renewal by Andersen office or visit the company’s website to schedule an in-home consultation.
- During your appointment, one of the company’s design consultants will visit your home, take measurements, and discuss the best window options to meet your needs. At this point, you’ll also receive a quote for your window installation.
- A project technician takes final measurements and reviews the scope of your upcoming window installation. If everything sounds good, the technician submits the final measurements so they can begin manufacturing your windows.
- Once your windows are ready, you’ll schedule a date for your installation. Depending on the scope, installation may take between a few hours and several days. Once installation is complete, the crew handles all of the cleanup, answers any remaining questions, and reviews the high points of your warranty.
Renewal By Andersen Reviews
Renewal by Andersen has over 4,200 reviews across Google Reviews, Trustpilot, and the BBB. We read approximately 45 reviews on each site, looking for common praise and complaints to gain a comprehensive understanding of customer experiences.
Customers with positive experiences leave glowing feedback about the quality of their windows and the installation process, while most negative reviews mention disappointment with pricing and poor communication early in the sales process.
We chose these reviews because they include the most common themes we found when reading customer feedback. While Stephanie M. felt the total process took longer than necessary, she felt the quality of her windows and the craftsmanship of the company’s installation crew made up for their relaxed pace. She also acknowledged that the windows were costly but felt the quality justified the price.
Breakdown by Review Site
We read reviews for Renewal by Andersen on Google Reviews, Trustpilot, and the BBB. Here’s what we found:
- BBB: Renewal by Andersen is BBB-accredited and maintains an A+ rating. Customers rate the company 2.97 out of 5 stars. Renewal by Andersen regularly responds to customer complaints.
- Trustpilot: The company is verified on Trustpilot and currently has a rating of 1.6 out of 5 stars. The company hasn’t responded to any negative feedback.
- Google Reviews: Renewal by Andersen has its highest rating on Google Reviews–4.9 out of 5 stars. The company often thanks its customers for their glowing feedback.
Renewal by Andersen maintains higher Google Reviews and BBB ratings, likely due to its habit of addressing customer complaints, which mostly mention disappointment about pricing and poor communication by the company when scheduling consultations.
While the company’s Trustpilot score is lower than expected, it wouldn’t be fair to compare it to Champion, which has a score of 4.2 out of 5 stars. Champion also has over 3,800 ratings on Trustpilot compared to the roughly 170 for Renewal by Andersen. Overall, people who choose Renewal by Andersen are pleased with the product and its installation despite the slower pace.
*All review scores were accurate when published.
Compare Renewal by Andersen to Other Window Brands
Renewal by Andersen stands out among its closest competitors for its high-quality frame material. However, it lags behind some because it offers fewer customer support options.
| Company | Star Rating | Best For | Price Range | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Selection | $680-$2,700 | GET ESTIMATE | ||
| Sunrooms | $400-$850 | GET ESTIMATE | ||
| Warranty | $300-$500 | GET ESTIMATE | ||
| Coastal Homes | $250-$900 | GET ESTIMATE | ||
| Wooden Windows | $500-$1,350 | GET ESTIMATE | ||
| Specialty Windows | $200-$600 | GET ESTIMATE | ||
| Eco-Friendly Windows | $450-$2,000 | GET ESTIMATE |
Is Renewal by Andersen Worth It?
As our highest-rated window company reviewed, Renewal by Andersen is worth it. Its frames remain durable throughout seasonal temperature changes because of its patented Fibrex material, providing excellent returns on investment. Additionally, its windows have ENERGY STAR and NFRC certifications, showcasing their energy efficiency and ability to help you save money on your heating and cooling costs.
Renewal by Anderson offers many of the most popular types of windows, including double-hung and casement windows, as well as specialty windows such as arched, round, and pentagon-shaped. This increases the likelihood that you’ll only need to work with one window company to handle all the replacements at your home, although it doesn’t offer single-hung windows. Because it offers a variety of colors for its window frames and hardware, you can easily customize your windows to match your home’s style.
While the company’s Trustpilot score is undoubtedly on the low end, it hasn’t received as many ratings there as it has on Google Reviews, where the feedback is overwhelmingly positive. Additionally, Renewal by Andersen maintains a higher BBB rating than many competitors, including Pella and Champion.
If you’re looking for exceptional quality windows that will last for decades, help reduce your heating and cooling costs, and come with a transferable warranty, Renewal by Andersen is an excellent choice.
Renewal by Andersen FAQ
What is the warranty for Renewal by Andersen windows?
Renewal by Andersen’s windows come with a transferable limited warranty. It covers installation for two years and the window’s frame and glass for 20 years. The warranty also covers hardware such as hinges and locks for 10 years.
What color windows does Renewal by Andersen offer?
Renewal by Andersen offers nine different color options, including white, forest green, black, and dark bronze. While you can choose your windows’ interior and exterior colors, the company only allows certain color combinations.
What is the most popular window that Renewal by Andersen sells?
Our research showed that the Acclaim double-hung window is the most popular window that Renewal by Andersen sells. Because of its clean design and various potions for check rails and hardware, it can feel equally at home on a historical residence as a modern one.
Is Renewal by Andersen better than Champion Windows?
Based on our rating methodology, Renewal by Andersen is objectively better than Champion Windows. Champion falls short in key areas, such as the lack of a transferable warranty, lower customer satisfaction scores, and no high-quality frame materials. However, unlike Champion, Renewal by Andersen doesn’t offer mid—or low-grade frame materials, which may exclude more budget-conscious homeowners. Champion also offers siding services, which can be an added convenience over hiring multiple contractors.
How We Chose the Top Window Brands
We researched and analyzed dozens of window manufacturers. Then, we crafted a rating system based on each brand’s standard product offerings and energy-efficient options for windows and doors.
We speak directly to a representative at each company to learn how the installation process with each provider works and determine how each brand personalizes its custom windows for each home. We also closely analyzed each company’s warranty options to ensure their product and labor guarantees match or exceed industry standards.
Other factors include the manufacturer’s years of experience and customer reputation. In addition, we analyzed the 100 most recent Google Reviews for each provider across various locations and branches.
