Best Gutter Guards for Metal Roofs | 2024 Review

By Shane Sentelle Updated February 6, 2024

Table of Contents

The Top Gutter Guards of 2024
Types of Gutter Guards
Why Do I Need Gutter Guards?
What Should I Look for in Gutter Guards?
Our Recommendation

All products and services featured are independently selected by our editors. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The right gutter guard for your home depends on many factors, including the type of roofing system you have. Some gutter guards are more compatible with certain roofing materials and may not be a universal fit. We’ve extended our research on the best gutter guards to highlight the top options for homes with metal roofs.

The Top Gutter Guards of 2024

Here are our picks for the best gutter guard brands:

LeafFilter

LeafGuard

HomeCraft Gutter Protection

All American Gutter Protection

Raptor Gutter Guard

Compare the Top Gutter Guards for Metal Roofs

Brand	BBB Rating	Link
LeafFilter	A+	Visit Site
LeafGuard	A+	Visit Site
Gutter Guards America	A+	Visit Site
All American	A	Visit Site
HomeCraft	B	Visit Site

LeafFilter

LeafGuard

Gutter Guards America

All American

HomeCraft

LeafFilter
Logo
Product Image
Star Rating
BBB Rating	A+

Visit Site

LeafGuard
Logo
Product Image
Star Rating
BBB Rating	A+

Visit Site

Gutter Guards America
Logo
Product Image
Star Rating
BBB Rating	A+

Visit Site

All American
Logo
Product Image
Star Rating
BBB Rating	A

Visit Site

HomeCraft
Logo
Product Image
Star Rating
BBB Rating	B

Visit Site

Providers

Star Rating

BBB Rating

Best For

Visit Site

A+

Best Overall

Visit Site

A+

Best Reverse-Curve

Visit Site

A+

Best Customer Reviews

Visit Site

Best Customization Options

Visit Site

Best Add-On Services

Types of Gutter Guards

Below, we’ve detailed the most common types of gutter guards available for professional and DIY installation.

Brush

Foam

Screen

Mesh Type

Reverse-Curve

Brush-style gutter guards, or gutter brushes, are a common DIY solution. These tightly bristled gutter inserts resemble large pipe cleaners, capturing debris between the bristles. They are easy to install but will become clogged over time, so they require frequent cleaning. Gutter brushes lack effectiveness against many types of small debris, such as pine needles.

Foam gutter guards, another common DIY option, are typically the most cost-effective solution. Installation requires simply inserting the foam gutter guard sections directly into your home’s gutter; there’s no need for any tools other than a ladder. These gutter guards suffer from durability issues and break down quicker than other designs in severe weather and sun exposure.

Gutter screens attach to the top of your home’s existing gutter system. Depending on the manufacturer, the gutter guard might simply clip on, or it might require fasteners. Screen gutter guards are available in several materials, including vinyl and aluminum. These gutter guards funnel water through small holes and tend to have better debris filtration than brush and foam gutter guards.

Mesh gutter guards are similar to gutter screens but have holes that are smaller in diameter, allowing for better debris filtration. Micro-mesh gutter guards contain minuscule, tightly spaced holes that can block debris as fine as shingle grit and pollen. These are among the most high-quality gutter guards available.

A reverse-curve gutter guard has an outward curve that covers the top of your home’s rain gutters. Rainfall adheres to this curve and runs into the gutter system, while debris falls from the curve onto the ground below. This gutter guard style can attach to your existing gutter system, or it may come as a one-piece design that serves as a full gutter replacement.

LeafFilter

4.8

Material: Stainless steel, unplasticized polyvinyl chloride (uPVC)
Warranty length: Lifetime warranty

What We Like

The LeafFilter gutter guard uses an ultrafine micro-mesh filter that attaches to your gutter system with a durable uPVC frame. It requires professional installation by a certified LeafFilter installer who will mount hidden hangers to reinforce your existing gutter system. The gutter guard’s low-profile design matches well with most roofing styles, including metal roofs.

We like LeafFilter’s debris filtration capability, blocking debris as fine as pollen. This level of filtration is possible due to the 275-micron mesh design, a much smaller measurement for its openings than many similar designs. Plus, LeafFilter backs its product with a lifetime transferable warranty.

What Homeowners are Saying

We read dozens of the most recent LeafFilter customer reviews on third-party websites, including Google Reviews and TrustPilot. Many customers compliment the professionalism of LeafFilter’s installers. We also noted timeliness as a common theme. Less satisfied customers mention customer service issues, citing communication lapses and a sometimes pushy sales process.

LeafGuard

Material: Aluminum
Warranty length: Lifetime finish warranty

What We Like

We like LeafGuard for its one-piece aluminum construction that combines new gutters with built-in gutter protection. The LeafGuard gutter system has a seamless design, providing greater protection against leaks than sectional gutters.

The built-in reverse-curve gutter guard uses liquid adhesion to direct water into the gutter while depositing debris onto the surrounding ground. This design is effective against many types of debris but may still allow minute material to enter the gutter system. LeafGuard comes with a transferable lifetime finish warranty that provides protection against scratching, chipping, and other superficial damage.

What Homeowners are Saying

Based on recent customer reviews on the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and Trustpilot, we noted that customers often speak about their professional and friendly interactions with the LeafGuard sales staff. Other positive reviews express satisfaction with the gutter guard system’s performance. Several mixed and negative reviews mention communication issues with LeafGuard and high estimates.

HomeCraft

4.2

Material: Stainless steel, powder-coated aluminum
Warranty length: Lifetime warranty

What We Like

The HomeCraft gutter guard has a durable, stainless-steel, micro-mesh design attached to an aluminum frame. It features a unique raised pattern that helps lift debris away from your home’s gutter system while surface tension allows water to flow through. The all-metal construction is resistant to rust and corrosion.

HomeCraft requires professional installation and is only available in 12 states. It backs its gutter guard with a lifetime transferable warranty.

What Homeowners are Saying

We read many customer reviews for HomeCraft locations in Georgia, Tennessee, and North Carolina on Google Reviews. Our research also included customer reviews on the BBB. We learned that many customers enjoy their experience with knowledgeable and friendly HomeCraft sales representatives. Several positive reviews also note that the HomeCraft gutter guard performed to expectations.

A common complaint in mixed and negative reviews is that HomeCraft was unresponsive to issues reported about new gutter and gutter guard installations. Other customers mention receiving excessive calls from HomeCraft sales teams after requesting an estimate.

All American Gutter Protection

4.1

Material: Stainless steel, aluminum
Warranty length: Lifetime warranty

What We Like

All American Gutter Protection’s gutter guard features stainless-steel micro-mesh attached to an all-aluminum frame. Its design resists the warping and bending that can occur over time with cheaper materials, such as vinyl. Plus, the metal materials provide a pleasing aesthetic when paired with a metal roof.

All American is not available for DIY installations but requires a certified installer. It has locations in 18 states. All American’s lifetime performance warranty guarantees that its gutter guard will work as specified in your contract for as many years as you own your home.

What Homeowners are Saying

We looked at dozens of customer reviews for All American Gutter Protection on the BBB and Google Reviews. For Google Reviews, we focused on the company’s Charlotte, North Carolina, location. Satisfied customers compliment the company’s fast and professional installation. Several reviews also mention that All American provides fair estimates.

Some critical customer reviews mention issues with All American’s warranty agreement. These customers express frustration over poor communication when scheduling warranty repairs, noting that the company failed to follow up in some instances.

Raptor Gutter Guard

4.6

Material: Aluminum, stainless steel
Warranty length: 25-year warranty

What We Like

Raptor Gutter Guard is manufactured by Gutterglove and is the only brand in our rankings marketed for DIY installs. You can choose from an all-aluminum gutter screen or a stainless-steel, micro-mesh design. Both versions of the Raptor Gutter Guard are available on Amazon.

We like that Raptor Gutter Guard offers two gutter guard options, with its more high-end micro-mesh design providing greater debris filtration. Its 25-year warranty is better than many similar DIY brands but falls short of the lifetime warranties provided by the professional installers in our rankings.

What Homeowners are Saying

We reviewed recent customer feedback on Amazon for Raptor Gutter Guard. Overall, its products have positive reviews. Many customers note an easy installation and are happy with how the product performs. Some negative reviews mention that smaller debris, such as pine needles, collects on top of the mesh and requires regular cleaning.

Why Do I Need Gutter Guards?

Here are a few reasons you should consider buying a gutter guard for your home’s gutter system:

Damage prevention: By helping prevent clogged gutters, a gutter guard can protect your home from damage. Restricted water flow inside a gutter system due to clogs can cause water to spill over the side, potentially damaging your home’s fascia, siding, and foundation.
Pest control: When a rain gutter collects pockets of debris, it can become a prime nesting ground for various insects. A gutter guard helps prevent debris from entering your gutter, making it more difficult for insects to find nesting material.
Reduced gutter cleaning maintenance: No gutter guard will eliminate the risk of gutter clogs or the need for cleaning your gutters. However, a high-quality gutter guard will substantially reduce your gutter cleaning frequency and difficulty.

What Should I Look for in Gutter Guards?

When researching the best gutter guards for your home, consider the following factors.

DIY vs. Pro Installation

You must decide whether you want to install gutter guards yourself or hire a professional gutter contractor. DIY gutter guard installations may be difficult for those who lack experience working on a ladder and using basic tools and fasteners. Professional installations come at a higher price point, but you’ll benefit from experienced labor. Further, professionally installed gutter guards often come with extended warranties.

Material Types To Use

Metal gutter guard materials, such as stainless steel and aluminum, are more durable than vinyl. Aluminum is more lightweight than steel but may be more susceptible to warpage, especially when the aluminum is thin. Both stainless steel and aluminum are resistant to rust and corrosion, but stainless steel tends to resist corrosion for a longer period of time.

Types of Debris Buildup Prevented

A gutter guard purchase should factor in the types of roof and gutter debris you typically encounter. If your home is surrounded by conifers, you’ll want to avoid gutter guards that struggle with pine needles, such as gutter brushes. Generally, a micro-mesh gutter guard will offer the best protection against all debris types.

You should also read customer reviews to ensure the gutter guard doesn’t lead to spillover during heavy rain if you live in a rainy location.

Is There A Warranty Included

Review the terms and conditions of a gutter guard’s warranty before finalizing a purchase. Less-expensive DIY products tend to have limited warranties compared to professional installations.

Our Recommendation

Many gutter guards are compatible with metal roofing systems and can help keep your gutters clog-free. We recommend LeafFilter as our top option for its durable micro-mesh design that blocks most debris types. With small openings that measure 275 microns—or around one-hundredth of an inch—LeafFilter has one of the best debris filtration capacities on the market. LeafGuard is another good choice for homeowners who need a full gutter replacement, providing built-in gutter protection with its attractive reverse-curve design.

Before buying a gutter guard, ask a company representative what widths are available to ensure you can find a match for your home’s gutter size. You should request estimates from at least three gutter guard installers to compare prices and warranty terms.

Gutter Guards FAQ

Will installing a gutter guard void my roof warranty?

It’s crucial to review the terms and conditions of your home’s roof warranty before installing gutter guards. In many cases, a gutter guard will not void the warranty as long as the installation doesn’t damage the roofing system or require any roofing modifications.

What is the difference between a gutter cover and a gutter guard?

These terms are often used interchangeably. However, a gutter cover may refer to a reverse-curve design that drapes over the existing gutter system and funnels water into the gutter through liquid adhesion.

Do I still need to clean my gutters with a gutter guard?

Yes, you should still clean your gutters with a gutter guard. Having a gutter guard installed will reduce cleaning maintenance, but debris can still accumulate over time. Some cheaper gutter guards, such as foam gutter guards, will also need to be replaced frequently.

What is a transferable warranty?

A transferable warranty can be transferred to the new homeowner when you sell your home. Limitations often apply with this type of warranty, and it’s important to review the terms and conditions of your warranty agreement carefully.

How We Chose the Top Gutter Guard Providers

We researched and analyzed dozens of gutter guards and gutter guard companies to create an in-depth review methodology. We formulated a rating system based on the factors homeowners find most important. We evaluated each provider’s gutter guard design and aesthetics, service offerings, customer service and communication, quote process, warranties, and financing options.

We created a separate rating system for DIY-installed gutter guards sold on retailer sites. We evaluated these guards based on their quality of materials, aesthetics, communication, warranty, customer reviews, and cost.

We evaluated each provider’s reputation using independent, third-party sites such as the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and Google My Business pages. For products, we analyzed the customer reviews on whichever online retailer primarily hosts the product.